Owner review roundup · Tote
Portland Leather Almost Perfect Tote: What Owners Say
A summary of owner feedback on Portland Leather's Almost Perfect Tote, a cult-favorite leather tote sold with small cosmetic flaws at a lower price. What owners love and what to know first.
Owners love the soft full-grain leather, the price and the color choices, and many carry it daily. Watch for an unstructured, slouchy shape, the open top, and occasional smell or shape issues on arrival.
- Maker
- Portland Leather Goods
- Type
- Tote
- Material
- Full-grain leather, unlined
- Typical price
- About $100 to $150
Plain link, no commission. Prices change; check the listing.
What owners like
- Full-grain leather at a price well below most leather totes.
- Owners often say the "almost perfect" flaws are hard to find or don't matter.
- Soft and relatively light for a leather tote, even when carried full every day.
- A huge range of colors, and leather that owners say gets better with use.
What owners complain about
- Unstructured and slouchy, so it doesn't stand up on its own and small items sink.
- The classic version has an open top with no closure.
- A few buyers report a bag arriving slightly warped or misshapen.
- At least one buyer returned a tote over a chemical smell.
Buy it if
You want an everyday full-grain leather tote that softens with use, and you don't need a closure or structure.
Skip it if
You ride crowded transit and want a zip top, or you need a structured bag that holds a laptop upright.
The short version
The Almost Perfect Tote has a loyal following because it delivers soft, full-grain leather at a price most leather totes can’t touch. The “almost perfect” label refers to small cosmetic marks that many owners say they struggle to even find.
What you give up is structure and security: it’s a slouchy, open tote.
Who it works for
Owners who love it tend to use it as an everyday carry-all for errands, work and travel. They like that it softens and darkens over time, and that it doesn’t weigh much for a leather bag. If your day is mostly car, office and shops, it’s an easy recommendation from what owners report.
Who it frustrates
The open top is a real limitation on public transit, in crowds or when you set the bag down. The lack of structure means a laptop leans and small things disappear to the bottom. Adding a pouch or organizer insert helps a lot.
On arrival
Most feedback on arrival is positive, but a few buyers mention a warped shape or a chemical smell. Stuff the bag with paper to reshape it, air it out for a few days, and use the return window if it doesn’t settle. See how to care for a leather bag.
How it compares
Next to the Madewell Transport Tote, owners describe it as softer and more relaxed, and usually cheaper. The Madewell is a bit more polished and holds its shape better.
Frequently asked questions
What does "Almost Perfect" mean?
Portland Leather sells these bags at a lower price because of small cosmetic irregularities in the leather. The maker says the flaws don't affect quality or durability.
Does the Almost Perfect Tote have a zipper?
The classic tote is open at the top. The maker sells other tote styles with zippers if you need a closure.
Compare with
- TotePositive with caveats
Madewell Transport Tote
Madewell · About $170 to $200
Long-term owners say it holds its shape, softens nicely and lasts for years. The caveats are dye transfer on lighter colors, an open top, and leather that one buyer felt was more corrected-grain than full-grain.
BriefcasePositive with caveatsSaddleback Classic Briefcase
Saddleback Leather · About $600 to $900 by size
Owners who've carried it for years say it's close to indestructible and ages beautifully. The most common regret is weight, and a few wish it had more modern laptop padding.
MessengerMostly positivePolare Full Grain Leather Messenger Bag
Polare · About $150 to $220
Buyers generally praise the leather, the look and the smooth metal zippers for the price. The recurring cautions are color rub-off early on and laptop fit on some sizes.